Vince's New York Pizza

Unlike some whiney guy complaining for 1,000 words on here about lasagna and the fact that this place, in the middle of nowhere, isn't plated fine dining, let's focus on reality: it's good, solid pizza.

The crust is crunchy outside and soft inside and it has a great flavor. The sauce is sweeter than I personally like, but still good. Toppings were good. I had veggie, my friend had pepperoni. We were both pleasantly surprised with how good the pizza was. We'll be back.

Excellent pizza and Italian dishes. Roberto and his staff always do an excellent job. Fresh baked bread is a plus. I've never been disappointed with any of our selections.

The owner is the sweetest human. The pizza is great! Definitely recommend if you're looking for a laid back pizza place.

This place was fine. The pizza and appetizers were good. There didn't appear to be any table service as they just handed things over the counter as they were ready. No one else was in the place though, so it wasn't because they were too busy.

Many people may not care, but they don't wear gloves or separate duties. In other words, the person taking money, touching food, and cleaning are the same person. Again, I understand this is not a big deal to some.

Inconsistent, fries lack size regularity, crispness, sauce is it there, flavor?
Cooks look at you ad another order.

I don't have a cousin named Vinny but I have been to NY, so having an authentic pizzeria in the small town of Smithsburg is definitely no crime.

I wanted to take in the humble space but instead my family decided to order delivery. Now I wasn't on the phone but heard it was free, (we lived 0.6mi away) bonus!

We ordered a medium pepperoni and a large mixed veggie with Italian sausage. They arrived piping hot with fresh cut veggies and plenty of meats. Im not sure if they were house made but the onions were julienned rings instead of diced which I liked and it helped with caramelization.
The sauce to cheese ratio was perfect for me without either overwhelming the other ingredients. And the most important part, the crust, was both chewy and light. Both pizzas were pretty stretched in their boxes almost gaining an inch and although I would have personally liked it a bit more well done, it was still a solid pie.

I looked up their website and realized the menu is extensive! So I better go check out a calzone, chocolate dipped cannoli or some Sicilian style pizza! I also saw the medium pizza is 14" and the 16" large ($12.99) is just a dollar more.

Thats almost better than scoring a date with Mona Lisa Vito! Way to go Vince, I will be spinning my wheels to get back before you can say posi-traction!

Typical pizza joint inside, but clean and neat, and the food is fantastic. Wonderful hot, delicious pizza and their steak and cheese sub is one of the best I've had. We used to frequent another pizza place in town but it has really gone downhill with the food. Vince's is now my go to place to eat in Smithsburg. It never disappoints and the owners are very friendly

Had carry-out here for the first time, this evening. When I walked in the owner warmly greeted me, then continued to ask questions being genuinely interested in me as a person not just a customer. I watched as a few others came and went, which he knew by name. The food was absolutely amazing and I couldn't be happier that I found this place!! It is our new default/go-to

It was unexpected to find such excellent pizza in little smithsburg but being from new York I have high expectations for pizza and Vince's did not disappoint. Ambience is a typical pizza joint, a bit on the dumpy side but the staff was friendly, the food came out fast and it was delicious. My dining companions got steak and cheese subs and a gyro and everyone loved their food.

We stopped in this cold morning for a bit of pie just after they opened at 11. They took great care of us and the pies were most excellent! The staff brought out the very hot and tasty pizzas, the sauce was spot on, the crust was also nice and the fresh cheese that I think they make on site was very good. Our two large pies hit the spot. We will definitely make this our lunch stop on our motorcycle rides.