11/24/2009
Karl "Kid Don Cornelius" R. says:
It was noted that the Ontario government used to subsidize the fare (ie the operating budget) but now the Ontario government contributes nothing. It's long been said the TTC is the only transit system that funds most of its daily operations out of the fare box. Back in 2000, the Ontario government contributed about 50% to the operating budget.
Coincidentally, back in 2000, both levels of government started cutting income tax rates. We get to keep a lot more of our pay today than we did 9 years ago. The GST has fallen a couple % points as well.
We enjoyed the tax cuts but this started the whole phenomenon of "downloading". Stuff the feds used to pay for, they stopped. Municipal stuff Ontario used to pay for, they stopped. User fees started to be added to things that used to be for free (maybe for example, admission to national parks). Or fees were increased (license plates).
In some ways, that's not a bad thing. If I'm not a camper, why should I subsidize someone else's hobby? You're not a driver, why should you subsidize my roads? We can keep more of our pay. What we no longer pay in taxes we can be more judicious about where it goes for government services that used to be "free".
So, alas, the TTC has to fund more and more out of the fare box and we who use the TTC have to pay more and more of the real cost. There's certainly an argument to be made that a $1 the Ontario government invests in public transit pays dividends across the board, just as Hydro finds it better to pay us to use energy saver lights.
It comes down, in a way, to what you value? Lower taxes and more fee for services you specifically use. Or higher taxes and getting a win in the public transit column but also understanding you're paying for the other guy's roads, university education, and daycare.
Of course the other debate is squarely with the TTC. We're paying 80% of their operating budget. Are we getting value for our money? Does it please you you got no raise this year but you know that guy in the booth would burn police cars if he didn't get his 5% raise this year? And he won't tell you which way is downtown?
Anyway, thinking like this is all I can do to keep my blood from boiling.