Overhyped Restaurants In Toronto

See All Lists
Don't believe the hype. I caution against trusting the rave reviews here - go (or don't) and form your own opinion, but don't blindly follow the crowd! These places aren't "all that."

 1. Pizzeria Libretto

221 Ossington Ave
Toronto, ON M6J 2Z8
Canada
(416) 532-8000

Categories: Pizza, Italian

Neighborhoods: Little Portugal, Ossington Strip, Trinity Bellwoods, Beaconsfield Village

2.0 star rating
  2/16/2009

After reading all of the rave reviews in Toronto's local papers, I was expecting a lot more than I got after my first visit! As warned, the lineup was out the door and it took about 30 minutes to get a table for four people.

The menu was a lot…More »

Was this review …?

 2. Cafe 668

885 Dundas St W
Toronto, ON M6J 1V9
Canada
(416) 703-0668

Categories: Vegetarian, Vietnamese

Neighborhoods: Little Italy, Trinity Bellwoods

2.0 star rating
  2/9/2009

Like other reviewers, I found the food a bit disappointing considering the price. Mediocre. For food that's just as good but more affordable for bigger portions, I'd just go to Salad King!

Was this review …?

 3. Uno Mustachio

93 Front St E
Toronto, ON M5E 1C2
Canada
(416) 367-8325

Categories: Italian, Sandwiches

Neighborhoods: St. Lawrence, Downtown Core

1.0 star rating
  1/13/2010

SUMMARY FOR SHORT ATTENTION SPANS: All hype. Don't bother.

This is going to be another barnburner. No longer can I sit idly by while so many others blindly and foolishly hype this place beyond what's reasonable. I'd been here a few times pre-Yelp and…More »

Was this review …?

 4. Poutini's House of Poutine

1112 Queen St W
Toronto, ON M6J 1H9
Canada

Category: Fast Food

Neighborhoods: West Queen West, Beaconsfield Village

2.0 star rating
  12/3/2009

I dunno. Poutini's wasn't more than OK. For a place that specializes in JUST poutine, the flavour was weaker than a lot of other venues that serve a hundred other things but happen to count poutine among their offerings (Utopia, BQM, Betty's, etc.).

More »

Was this review …?

 5. El Sol Mexican Art Cafe

1448 Danforth Ave
Toronto, ON M4J 1N4
Canada
(416) 405-8074

Category: Mexican

Neighborhood: The Danforth

2.0 star rating
  7/31/2009

The decor in El Sol is amusing and very fitting - no fewer than 2500** clay suns of all sizes and designs adorn the walls from floor to ceiling, and they all appeared to be one of a kind. I ordered the "Tacos Albañil" - two soft tacos stuffed with…More »

Was this review …?

 6. Peter's Cajun Creole Pizza

415 Parliament St
Toronto, ON M5A 2Z4
Canada
(416) 368-8099

Categories: Cajun/Creole, Pizza

Neighborhood: Cabbagetown

2.0 star rating
  11/2/2009

The most expensive pizza I've ever (not) eaten, next to Magic Oven, and the latter's got organic/specialty ingredients that you didn't even know you wanted on a pizza in the first place.

$15.80 for a small "Jazz Cajun" pie with two toppings (sundried…More »

Was this review …?

 7. Ted's Collision

573 College St
Toronto, ON M6G 1B2
Canada
(416) 533-2430

Categories: Dive Bars, Pubs, Restaurants

Neighborhoods: Little Italy, Palmerston, Bickford Park

3.0 star rating
  Update - 1/29/2010

I've discovered the secret to Ted's: come before 11 if you're meeting friends for conversation! 11pm and onwards are the witching hours, when the volume gets cranked and unpopular music starts playing. Tonight (pre-11pm) we got to listen to The…More »

Was this review …?

1 Previous Review: Show all »

  • 3.0 star rating
    3/5/2009

    Like everyone else who's reviewed Ted's, I agree that the music is unspeakably loud. This is NOT the… Read more »

 8. Salad King Restaurant

340 Yonge St
Toronto, ON M5B 1R8
Canada
(416) 593-0333

Category: Thai

Neighborhoods: Ryerson, Downtown Core

3.0 star rating
  Update - 10/27/2009

In the past year I haven't had a five star experience at Salad King so I have to revoke my previous rating. This past Saturday the rice was unspeakably bad. How can a Thai restaurant not know how to steam a pot of rice?? I can't look past that,…More »

Was this review …?

1 Previous Review: Show all »

  • 5.0 star rating
    2/18/2009

    This isn't the place to take a first date or to catch up with long lost friends (for that it's… Read more »


Recently updated lists from Kat F.

Amsterdam Essentials (3)

February Review Challenge (13)

Top Beaches in Hawaii (9)

There are hundreds of beaches to choose from on Oahu and Kauai - here's my rundown of the best of them.

List Of Things For New Yorkers To Do In Toronto (28)

Do these things if you're visiting from NYC and want to see cool stuff.

Best Hot Chocolate In Toronto (7)

If you don't have Camino or Green & Black's Organic cocoa crystals on hand at home, please don't bother mixing up your own mug of hot chocolate - leave it to these experts!

My Favourite Meals Worldwide (15)

I've done a junkload of travelling in 2008/2009, and here's a list of the best meals I had!

Kat's List Of Things To Do: NYC Eats (10)

Some places I dined at on my most recent trip to NYC!

Stationery & Art Supplies: Or, Stores Where I Tend To Overspend (2)

If you love fancy pens, gorgeous paper and vellum, head here when you've got money and hours to burn.

Overstimulated in SF (3)

The best places to get caffeinated in San Francisco.

Toronto's Most Terrifying Toilets (9)

Descend at your own risk! The basement washrooms at these otherwise reputable establishments are terrifying, to say nothing of the actual hygiene of the facilities. Think "haunted house"-level scary. Be careful!

See all 103 lists »

"Get ready for greatness!"

Ambassador

Review votes:
6225 Useful, 4215 Funny, and 3874 Cool

Location

San Francisco, CA

Yelping Since

February 2009

Things I Love

criminally dark chocolate, accordions, Jonny Greenwood, John Frusciante, cashmere, graph paper, heirloom beans, Dogme 95, Peter Cetera, dimples, Dr. Mario, lengthy makeouts, winklepickers

My Hometown

Toronto, Canada

When I'm Not Yelping...

I'm fantasizing about Bob Harper

My Second Favourite Website

http://breadpeople.tum...

The Last Great Book I Read

The Crying Of Lot 49

My First Concert

Metallica (...And Justice for All)

My Favourite Movie

Shallow Grave

My Last Meal On Earth

Pâté Chinois

Don't Tell Anyone Else But...

I hate having dirty feet

Most Recent Discovery

Black Queen: http://www.youtube.com...

Current Crush

blue eyes & dimples