My Pizza List

See All Lists
A list of the best and worst pizzas in and out of town.

 1. Lombardi's Pizza

32 Spring St
New York, NY 10012
USA
(212) 941-7994

Category: Pizza

Neighbourhood: Nolita

5.0 star rating
  4/8/2009

The best pizza yet to touch my lips.

I heard about this place from many of my friends. I was surprised by the amount of recommendations to visit one place so I figured it was a sign.

After shopping all day in Soho my feet were tired, I was extremely…More »

Was this review …?

 2. Grimaldi's Pizzeria

16535 Southwest Fwy
Sugar Land, TX 77479
USA
(281) 265-2280

Category: Pizza

5.0 star rating
  5/11/2009

Been to Grimaldi's in Brooklyn more than enough times. The Sugar Land location is the same and in some cases better.

The pizza is right on par with it's Brooklyn counterpart. I managed to come at 5:15 right after they stoked the fire. The pizza came…More »

Was this review …?

 3. Mangia & Bevi

260 King Street East
Toronto, ON M5R 4L5
(416) 203-1635

Categories: Italian, Pizza

Neighbourhood: Corktown

5.0 star rating
  10/16/2009

M&B does pizza and they do it right. Probably the best thin crust pizza in Toronto. Step inside if you can find it. There are 2 entrances, one on Ontario St. that has some sort of M&B signage, another on king inside the office building. I recommend…More »

Was this review …?

 4. Danforth Pizza House

920 Danforth Ave
Toronto, ON M4J 1L9
(416) 463-4927

Category: Pizza

Neighbourhood: The Danforth

5.0 star rating
  9/30/2009 ROTD 8/24/2010

This is probably one of the smallest and sketchiest pizza places I've been to. Although, not as small as Bitondo's it is much sketchier as the place is empty, sticky counters, chairs are worn and plastic, and paint peeling from the walls.

You are…More »

Was this review …?

 5. Beerbistro

18 King St E
Toronto, ON M5C 1C4
(416) 861-9872

Categories: Canadian (New), Bars

Neighbourhoods: St. Lawrence, Downtown Core

5.0 star rating
  5/5/2009

I have found my new favorite place to grab pints and pints of, the gift the gods have given us, beer.

I came here yesterday with 3 people to grab a pint and maybe catch the Jays game. I didn't realize that this place had an after work crowd and felt…More »

Was this review …?

 6. Pizza Pino

855 Westney Rd S
Ajax, ON L1S 3M4
(905) 683-4946

Category: Pizza

5.0 star rating
  4/3/2009 First to Review

The most flavorful thick crust pizza in the Toronto area by far!!!!

I usually like thin crust authentic pizzas. Lombardi's in New York is my all time favorite but this place has reshaped my thoughts on thick crust. Each slice is heavily topped and has…More »

Was this review …?

 7. San Leone's

1678 Broadway
New York, NY 10019
USA
(212) 265-1414

Category: Pizza

Neighbourhoods: Midtown West, Theater District

4.0 star rating
  4/13/2009

It's hard to find a good cheap slice around Times Square that isn't a tourist trap. Leone's is a diamond in the rough disguised as coal. I've walked past Leone's several times without noticing it but always noticed the sweet aroma of fresh tomato…More »

Was this review …?

 8. Bitondo's Pizzeria

11 Clinton St
Toronto, ON M6J 2N7
(416) 533-4101

Categories: Pizza, Italian

Neighbourhood: Little Italy

4.0 star rating
  8/8/2009 ROTD 3/16/2010

So far the best no-fuss, non-gourmet, New York style pizza I've had in Toronto. I knew there were a lot of Italians in our city but I could never find a great slice until I walked into this hole in the wall of Bitondo's.

This place is nestled nicely…More »

Was this review …?

 9. Grazie Ristorante

2373 Yonge St
Toronto, ON M4P 2C8
(416) 488-0822

Category: Italian

Neighbourhoods: Mount Pleasant and Davisville, Yonge and Eglinton

4.0 star rating
  1/1/2010

This place has won me over and it may be because it is deeply rooted in my childhood memories. As a young lad playing baseball my team was sponsored by Grazie Ristorante and my third base coach was the owner. But either way it's still a great place…More »

Was this review …?

 10. Krunch Pizza Bar

980 2nd Ave
New York, NY 10022
USA
(212) 207-4122

Category: Pizza

Neighbourhood: Midtown East

4.0 star rating
  4/11/2009

With flavors like Buffalo Chicken, that actually taste just like a chicken wing and even has finely diced carrots and celery, and Cheeseburger Krunch; the pizza found at Krunch Pizza Bar is not your traditional slice. The square slices live up to…More »

Was this review …?

 11. Terroni

57A Adelaide Street E
Toronto, ON M5C 1K6
(416) 203-3093

Category: Italian

Neighbourhood: Downtown Core

4.0 star rating
  4/18/2009

Terroni I love you. You are very good to me. Always feeding me delicious pastas and pizzas, trying to get me fatter. I can't hate you for that, you're just doing what you do best. You're only fault is you don't take reservations and think you are too…More »

Was this review …?

 12. Pizzeria Libretto

221 Ossington Ave
Toronto, ON M6J 2Z8
(416) 532-8000

Categories: Pizza, Italian

Neighbourhoods: Little Portugal, Ossington Strip, Trinity Bellwoods, Beaconsfield Village

3.0 star rating
  4/3/2009

This place is quaint. VERY quaint. Basically it's a hallway with tables. Helped with the atmosphere though.

I went with 8 people and showed up before the rush. Luckily for me seating was a breeze and I got to try every pizza on the menu. Pizza's were…More »

Was this review …?

 13. Pizza Rustica

270 Wellington St W
Toronto, ON M5V 3P5
(416) 260-0200

Categories: Pizza, Italian

Neighbourhoods: Entertainment District, Downtown Core

2.0 star rating
  6/1/2009

This place just doesn't do it for me. I've been a few times and it just doesn't do it. Although the decor is nice and service is decent the pizzas are just sad. They aren't anything special, sure they are better than Pizza Pizza but that's not a hard…More »

Was this review …?

 14. California Pizza Kitchen

1120 Broadway Plz
Walnut Creek, CA 94596
USA
(925) 938-0720

Category: Pizza

2.0 star rating
  4/12/2009

The location of this CPK is a good and inexpensive in comparison to other restaurants surrounding it. There are many nice shops surrounding this location and would make a good place to have lunch and enjoy the sun California has to offer on the…More »

Was this review …?

 15. Ray's Pizza

1710 Broadway
New York, NY 10019
USA
(212) 247-7901

Categories: Pizza, Italian

Neighbourhood: Midtown West

1.0 star rating
  4/12/2009

Being my first time in New York I expected all pizza places to be decent at worst. Not Ray's! This place is absolutely disgusting. Pizza tastes like cardboard, simply bland. I couldn't taste anything, the toppings, the sauce, the cheese, the crust,…More »

Was this review …?


Recently updated lists from Jay G.

My Favorite Restaurants (8)

My favorite places to eat from here and there.

"Food eater extraordinaire."

Review votes:
565 Useful, 186 Funny, and 325 Cool

Location

Toronto, ON

Yelping Since

April 2009

Things I Love

food, travel, interwebs

Find Me In

Toronto, Houston, San Francisco, San Diego, New York, Los Angeles, Vancouver

My Hometown

Houston, TX / San Francisco, CA

When I'm Not Yelping...

I'm traveling the globe

Why You Should Read My Reviews

Been around the world and I, I, I.

My Second Favourite Website

http://www.buzzfeed.com

The Last Great Book I Read

jPod

My First Concert

Green Day and Blink 182

My Favourite Movie

Blow

My Last Meal On Earth

Southern home cookin

Don't Tell Anyone Else But...

We live in a society where pizza gets to your house before the police.

Most Recent Discovery

If I agreed with you, we would both be wrong.