In Search of the Perfect Cupcake

See All Lists
I cannot possibly try all the new cupcakeries that are popping up all over the place; I would be fatter than high school Monica on Friends. But here are some places I've tried.

 1. Morimoto Napa

610 Main St
Napa, CA 94559
(707) 252-1600
5.0 star rating
  6/21/2011

I have found the perfect cupcake.

Who would have thought Iron Chef Morimoto would win the cupcake war with a perfectly balanced, perfectly textured yellow cake with yuzu lemon curd filling and coconut frosting?  Not too sweet, not too heavy.  I loved…More »

Was this review …?

 2. Bebecakes Cupcakery - CLOSED

230 University Ave
Palo Alto, CA 94301
(650) 722-9528

Category: Bakeries

4.0 star rating
  4/12/2011

Drama Queen!  I think coconut cupcakes have taken over as my number one favorite.  I also brought a Latin Bombshell home for hubby.  (Aren't I the best wife ever?  Even if we *are* only talking about cupcakes...)  Bebecakes' cupcakes are very moist,…More »

Was this review …?

 3. Buttercup Bake Shop

973 2nd Ave
New York, NY 10022
(212) 350-4144

Categories: Bakeries, Coffee & Tea

Neighbourhood: Midtown East

4.0 star rating
  8/30/2006

I had read about the cupcake debate here and in a couple magazine articles, and thought it would be fun to try to find both Magnolia and Buttercup during my last visit to NYC.  Unfortunately, the line at Magnolia's was too long for a weekend tourist,…More »

Was this review …?

 4. Dick's Bakery

1593 Meridian Ave
San Jose, CA 95125
(408) 269-5212

Category: Bakeries

4.0 star rating
  Update - 10/26/2010

To help celebrate a friend's "50th lap around the sun," we ordered a half sheet of burnt almond cake from Dick's Bakery.  They decorated it with balloons with exactly the colors we requested and everyone at the party loved it.

Was this review …?

1 Previous Review: Show all »

  • 4.0 star rating
    6/18/2009

    Brought hubby a slice of burnt almond cake for his birthday and he really enjoyed it.  He also… Read more »

 5. Georgetown Cupcake

3301 M St NW
Washington, DC 20007
(202) 333-8448

Category: Bakeries

Neighbourhood: Georgetown

4.0 star rating
  12/28/2009

Earlier this year in April we happened to be in DC and saw an ad somewhere for Georgetown Cupcake.  This was prior to heading to Manhattan, where I thought I was going to pick up some highly desirable red velvets.  Well, long after our East Coast…More »

Was this review …?

 6. Icing on the Cake

50 W Main St
Los Gatos, CA 95030
(408) 354-2464

Categories: Bakeries, Desserts

4.0 star rating
  Update - 5/9/2009

I wasn't sure if Icing on the Cake offered cupcakes in their shop, but hubby confirmed this for me by surprising me one day and bringing home two red velvets and two vanilla coconuts.  The cake portions had decent flavor and density, and the cream…More »

Was this review …?

1 Previous Review: Show all »

  • 4.0 star rating
    12/21/2007

    I have to agree with rebecca a. -- get the banana cake.  I have friends who live in the gated… Read more »

 7. La Villa Delicatessen & Gourmet Shop

1319 Lincoln Ave
San Jose, CA 95125
(408) 295-7851
4.0 star rating
  Update - 1/23/2009

I just had a red velvet cupcake that was amazing.  I love everything at La Villa, except the long lines.

Was this review …?

1 Previous Review:

  • 4.0 star rating
    3/3/2006

    Ditto, Emily W.  The home-made ravioli is delicious...you must try it.

    Was this review …?

 8. Los Altos Bakery and Cafe

692 Fremont Ave
Los Altos, CA 94024
(650) 559-0382
4.0 star rating
  12/1/2007

Yay, another place that doesn't put celery in their chicken salad!  Being allergic to celery, I often have to pass up on chicken or tuna salad sandwiches.  Los Altos Bakery seasons their chicken salad with dill and black pepper.  It came on thick…More »

Was this review …?

 9. Stacks

361 California Dr
Burlingame, CA 94010
(650) 579-1384
4.0 star rating
  8/22/2006

Stacks is my restaurant of choice when it comes to meeting clients on the  Peninsula for breakfast.  On early weekday mornings, we usually get seated right away.  The food is nicely prepared in large portions, and I really enjoy the fresh blueberries…More »

Was this review …?

 10. Vanilla Moon Bakery

872 Laurel St
San Carlos, CA 94070
(650) 593-3015

Categories: Bakeries, Desserts

4.0 star rating
  Update - 4/4/2010

Just had to write another update for Vanilla Moon after picking up a special of the day, the Chocolate Graham Cracker S'Mores.  Yum!  Red Velvet is fast becoming my third favorite of all time, behind Georgetown Cupcake's vanilla coconut and this…More »

Was this review …?

2 Previous Reviews: Show all »

  • 4.0 star rating
    6/5/2009

    Funny how choosing a physical therapist in San Carlos just happens to put me within walking distance… Read more »

 11. Cosy Cave Bake Shoppe

208 Bear Street
Banff, AB T1L
Canada
(403) 762-0414

Category: Bakeries

3.0 star rating
  6/1/2010

I could not resist going into this cute bakery and trying at least ONE cupcake.  There were several flavors to choose from, and we settled on a simple vanilla cake with white frosting.  Nice density, good flavor, very good frosting.  A little too…More »

Was this review …?

 12. Sheng Kee Bakery

10961 N Wolfe Rd
Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 865-6000

Category: Bakeries

3.0 star rating
  5/1/2006

I have enjoyed almost everything, sweet and savory, that I've tried from the Cupertino shop.  Stick to the Asian-style breads.  You can easily find something for a quick take-out lunch, from pastry items to pre-made sandwiches on the counter.  Sheng…More »

Was this review …?

 13. Citizen Cake - CLOSED

399 Grove St
San Francisco, CA 94102
(415) 861-2228

Categories: Bakeries, American (Traditional), Desserts

Neighbourhood: Hayes Valley

2.0 star rating
  3/26/2006

Mom, little sis, and I had dinner here before the symphony.  Despite all accolades and high expectations, the food was just okay.  Desserts were not much more impressive, although you'll enjoy them more while sitting down at a table.  I have also…More »

Was this review …?

 14. Cupcake Jones

307 NW 10th Ave
Portland, OR 97209
(503) 222-4404

Categories: Bakeries, Desserts

Neighbourhood: Pearl District

2.0 star rating
  3/31/2010

I bought 5, yes 5, different flavored cupcakes from Cupcake Jones.  Although they are larger than the standard size, and pretty to look at, the cakes are dry and crumbly and totally lacking in flavor.  The frosting is on the thick side and also…More »

Was this review …?

 15. Kara's Cupcakes

3055 Olin Ave
San Jose, CA 95128
(408) 260-2222

Categories: Desserts, Bakeries

2.0 star rating
  3/21/2009

Since my diet's already been blown out of the water these past couple of months, why not try more cupcakes?  The Kara's vs. Sprinkles debate rages on, but in my opinion there is no debate.  Both are a complete waste of money.

To celebrate a friend's…More »

Was this review …?

 16. Miette Patisserie

1 Ferry Bldg
San Francisco, CA 94111
(415) 837-0300

Categories: Bakeries, Desserts

Neighbourhood: Embarcadero

2.0 star rating
  1/23/2009

I was disappointed to find the cupcakes (of various flavors) are only so-so here at Miette.  Although decorated quite beautifully, I am reminded of women who wear too much make-up...

The macarons are good and pretty close to what you might find in…More »

Was this review …?

 17. Sprinkles Cupcakes

393 Stanford Shopping Ctr
Palo Alto, CA 94304
(650) 323-9300

Category: Bakeries

2.0 star rating
  3/17/2009

Oh Sprinkles, how you disappoint me.  I really wanted to like this cute store and the goodies inside.  I also seriously jeopardized my waistline by trying 4 cupcakes before writing this review.  And considering how I hate writing bad reviews (less…More »

Was this review …?

 18. Sugar Butter Flour

1875 S Bascom Ave
Campbell, CA 95008
(408) 371-5485
2.0 star rating
  10/2/2008

What is it about cupcakes in California?  Do they need to be as dry as the baked earth that makes up this Golden State?

SBF's Red Velvet did not come close to New York's version...it was reasonably dense, but bland as could be.  I didn't even finish…More »

Was this review …?

 19. The Cupcakery

3770 Las Vegas Blvd S
Las Vegas, NV 89109
(702) 730-7533

Category: Desserts

Neighbourhood: The Strip

2.0 star rating
  1/12/2010

I was actually dancing in the hallway when I saw all the unexpected, beautiful cupcakes ahead of me.  We picked up two red velvets, an Oh - My Gosh, Ganache!, and a coconut vanilla.  Unfortunately, the cupcakes look way better than they taste.  The…More »

Was this review …?

 20. Crumbs

124 University Pl
New York, NY 10003
(212) 206-8011

Category: Bakeries

Neighbourhoods: Greenwich Village, Union Square

1.0 star rating
  4/22/2009

Walking into the store I was hit by the sickly sweet smell of fried doughnuts.  That should have been enough warning for me, as I don't like doughnuts.  But I was in New York!  I wanted a Red Velvet cupcake!

Sitting in Union Square Park, I took one…More »

Was this review …?


Recently updated lists from Sherri C.

When Romance is in the Air... (12)

...these are some of the places guaranteed to serve up a memorable experience for that special occasion.

Reasonable South Bay Dining Options (36)

Places you can visit regularly for decent meals without breaking the bank.

Ramen From South Bay to South Bay (17)

Until there's more time to Yelp, here's the short list of ramen places I've been to from SF to LA.

Best Places to 'Cruz (4)

Where I like to go when I have the chance to get over the hill!

Late Night Places (6)

In search of places to eat after 9:00 pm, these are the restaurants where we often end up.

O Canada (13)

It could be the refreshing mountain air, the high altitude, or the fact that Canadian cooks are often of European descent.  I found Rocky Mountain cuisine to be above-average delicious and the bread served at every restaurant was unique and awesome.

Sherri's Bay Area Sushi and Sashimi Experiences (59)

Fresh fish is not a luxury, but a must-have, and after downing this staple at least two or three times a week, I still don't have as extensive a list as I should.  Maybe I need to up my intake frequency...

The One-Star List (14)

Most of the time I don't want to bother writing about the one-stars and when I do, it's probably because I wished I could give the place no stars or negative star ratings!

So Much to Do with So Little Time in Vegas... (48)

I've gone to Vegas so often you'd think I'd be bored of it, but every time I visit it is usually for a company event or tradeshow with not much time to check things out.  Also, the Strip seems to be in a constant state of new construction so it's never quite the same each time.

Palo Alto Places (18)

Some of my favorite places in PA to eat or hang out...

"Got any more treats...?"

Review votes:
440 Useful, 156 Funny, and 246 Cool

Location

San Jose, CA

Yelping Since

January 2006

Things I Love

my husband's smile, hiking with my dogs, fog on the coast, sunsets, organic ice cream sandwiches, mom, traveling, weekend naps, the sound of children laughing, taking photos, yoga, helping others, reading a good book, jewelry, soaking up the sun, baking, whitewater rafting, OMD, hugs, dark chocolate & fresh sushi

Find Me In

Jeans

My Hometown

Danville, CA

My Blog Or Website

http://www.sherrisgard...

When I'm Not Yelping...

I'm training adopted rescue pups (currently FOUR Chow mixes).

Why You Should Read My Reviews

I am much better at eating out than I am at cooking...

My Second Favourite Website

http://www.care2.com, http://www.gearthatgiv..., http://www.amazon.com, http://www.starzbunnyc...

The Last Great Book I Read

Sarah's Key by Tatiana de Rosnay

My First Concert

New Year's Eve with General Public

My Favourite Movie

Life, itself

My Last Meal On Earth

will probably have to be slurped through a straw...

Don't Tell Anyone Else But...

I was an extra in a Bruce Springsteen music video.

Most Recent Discovery

Loving Dubstep!

Current Crush

My hubby for the past 15.916667 years...