Food Item: Seafood - Places to GO

See All Lists
I adore seafood. I'd happily give up meat over seafood anytime. Here's a list of places that not only have a focus on seafood, but serve top-notch quality.

 1. Marea

240 Central Park S
New York, NY 10019
(212) 582-5100

Category: Seafood

Neighbourhood: Midtown West

5.0 star rating
  5/23/2010

I adore seafood and have high expectations of the quality and preparation that allows seafood to be best appreciated.  So it was with much anticipation and some trepidation that I tried Marea's creations.

Marea is located just south of the Maine…More »

Was this review …?

 2. Pearl Oyster Bar

18 Cornelia St
New York, NY 10014
(212) 691-8211

Categories: Seafood, Bars

Neighbourhood: West Village

5.0 star rating
  4/1/2012

It seems everywhere you look these days in food media, there are best-of lists: best donuts, best meatballs, best fried chicken, best cheap eats, and so on.  Highly subjective but useful for the food obsessed, who need ever more ways to categorize…More »

Was this review …?

 3. Le Bernardin

155 W 51st St
New York, NY 10019
(212) 554-1515

Category: Seafood

Neighbourhoods: Midtown West, Theater District

4.0 star rating
  3/25/2012

** 4.5 stars **

Le Bernardin is consistently and universally hailed as one of the best fine dining restaurants in New York City.  As a steadfast seafood fan, I hoped for a transcendent food experience in the class of Marea, my favorite fine dining…More »

Was this review …?

 4. Red Hook Lobster Pound

284 Van Brunt St
Brooklyn, NY 11231
(718) 858-7650

Category: Seafood Markets

Neighbourhood: Red Hook

4.0 star rating
  4/15/2011

Finally visited the Lobster Pound's store, on a relatively quiet stretch of Van Brunt.  Easily accessible by car but not so much by public transportation.  They're regulars at Brooklyn street fairs, where I've had their lobster rolls multiple times.…More »

Was this review …?

 5. Luke's Lobster

93 E 7th St
New York, NY 10009
(212) 387-8487

Category: Seafood

Neighbourhood: East Village

4.0 star rating
  5/20/2011

Tiny East Village location with only a small U-shape counter of high-stool seating so take-out will be the way to go.  Various lobster and catching paraphernalia all about, and a cool, huge chalkboard menu hangs over the ordering counter.

This is my…More »

Was this review …?

 6. Prima

58 E 1 St
Manhattan, NY 10003
(646) 559-4823

Category: Seafood

Neighbourhood: East Village

4.0 star rating
  2/6/2012

This lovely place is currently a hidden, neighborhood gem.  Opened just 3 months ago, Prima serves up coffee during the day but in the evenings, it combines a well-prepared seafood menu with cocktails courtesy of Summit Bar.

Small and cozy, warm and…More »

Was this review …?

 7. The John Dory Oyster Bar

1196 Broadway
New York, NY 10001
(212) 792-9000

Category: Seafood

Neighbourhoods: Midtown West, Flatiron

4.0 star rating
  5/22/2011

John Dory was a pre-dinner stop just to sample.  Based on that, I will be back to try a great deal more.  Nice corner location on Broadway with floor to ceiling windows, flooding the high-ceiling space with natural light.  There's a bar down the…More »

Was this review …?

 8. Maison Premiere

298 Bedford Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11211
(347) 335-0446

Categories: Seafood, Wine Bars, American (Traditional)

Neighbourhood: Williamsburg - South Side

4.0 star rating
  7/13/2011

The designers outdid themselves with the decor here; this aspect is worth coming to admire alone.  The look is deliberately (but successfully) salvaged and worn, starting with the unadorned exterior with no sign.  Past one of the multiple wooden…More »

Was this review …?

 9. Aquagrill

210 Spring St
New York, NY 10012
(212) 274-0505

Category: Seafood

Neighbourhood: South Village

3.0 star rating
  11/5/2011

A Greenwich Village stalwart for seafood, I'm surprised I never made a trip sooner.  Its actually quite small, with a buzzing bar scene up front and maybe 15 small tables beyond that.  Reservations are a must, it seems really popular with an…More »

Was this review …?

 10. Esca

402 W 43rd St
New York, NY 10036
(212) 564-7272

Category: Italian

Neighbourhoods: Hell's Kitchen, Midtown West, Theater District

3.0 star rating
  11/18/2010

Came for dinner recently.  The service from door to table and throughout dinner was friendly and considerate.  The dining area is separated into smaller rooms, creating a more intimate setting, with decor spare, classy, and warm.  

Specialty here is…More »

Was this review …?

 11. Ed's Lobster Bar

222 Lafayette St
New York, NY 10012
(212) 343-3236

Categories: Seafood, Diners, Bars

Neighbourhood: SoHo

3.0 star rating
  Update - 10/13/2010

So back for more, this time with a friend.  Also slipped in right before the dinner rush hour, when it got fairly packed (although no line out the door) on a Saturday evening.  Got the oyster sampler this time, and was again rewarded with wonderfully…More »

Was this review …?

1 Previous Review: Show all »

  • 3.0 star rating
    8/14/2010

    Came across Ed's incidentally on a Saturday afternoon while wandering the neighborhood and… Read more »

 12. Live Seafood

136-20 Roosevelt Ave
Flushing, NY 11354

Categories: Seafood, Food Stands, Chinese

Neighbourhoods: Downtown Flushing, Flushing

3.0 star rating
  7/5/2011 First to Review

This place is always hopping, with tanks of live lobsters to attract the customers who are being assaulted by all the sights and smells that New World Mall's food court has to offer.  They offer live lobsters and crabs, pulled out and dispatched when…More »

Was this review …?

 13. Lure Fishbar

142 Mercer St
New York, NY 10012
(212) 431-7676

Category: Seafood

Neighbourhood: SoHo

3.0 star rating
  1/29/2011

Came for Restaurant Week dinner, ordering the $35 prix fix (and trying most of it with my group) along with several other items off the regular menu.  Lure Fishbar is located in the middle of Soho, a large subterranean space that seems completely…More »

Was this review …?

 14. Brooklyn Fish Camp

162 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11215
(718) 788-3264

Category: Seafood

Neighbourhood: Park Slope

3.0 star rating
  12/26/2009

Visited twice, would consider this place a good choice if you're in the mood for seafood.  Always an impressive selection of different types of fish and shellfish, including specials on a blackboard.  Most are simply prepared, which makes sense to…More »

Was this review …?


Recently updated lists from Valery C.

Cuisine: Thai (3)

In a city surprisingly bereft of great Thai (or real, for that matter), here is a list of the best I've had in NYC.

Accommodations (13)

Keeping my hotels and other accommodation reviews together.

Eats by Neighborhood: Park Slope (18)

I used to spend a lot of time eating in Park Slope, since it was just a hop from work, and even though my wandering eyes are a bit enamored with other Bklyn neighborhoods at the moment, it still has destinations worth returning for and some more still on my to-go list.

Favorite NYC restaurants (10)

Those restaurants that I love, and can go back to over and over and never tire of.  There are no specific criteria, nor is it ever only food that makes it a favorite, nor is it the same for every one.  But it always multiple reasons, some intangible, at work.  Single specialty item spots excluded.

Food Item: Odyssey for Elite Sushi (6)

Perhaps I've been living under a rock, but after 15 East reassured me that excellent sushi exists in NYC, my friend and I decided to try every highly regarded sushi restaurant here.  Forget fusion, trendy, and fancy rolls.  This is sushi bar dining in the hands of the chef only.

Platt 101 (2012) (29)

Keeping track of the restaurants on Adam Platt of New York mag's 2012 list of NYC's top 101 restaurants.

Food Style: Tapas (5)

Small plates for sharing to go with drinks, is there a better way to dine?

Sifty Fifty (2011) (14)

Tracking the 50 favorite restaurants of Sam Sifton, the former NY Times food critic, as of 8/2011.  In alphabetical order.  Whether he will now update this remains to be seen ...

Eats by Neighborhood: Bensonhurst (9)

Never thought I'd see fit to make a Bensonhurst list.  And no question there's a dearth of destination places here, but its my neighborhood and here are some of the places I go to simply because its convenient.

Tasting menus tours (15)

The truest sign of the adventurous eater is that they gleefully surrender preference and thought to wizards in kitchens, enjoying a parade of tastes and savoring the surprise factor.  No need to worry that those in your party aren't ordering enough for you to try!

See all 39 lists »

"3 stars is not an insult"

Review votes:
438 Useful, 102 Funny, and 194 Cool

Location

Brooklyn, NY

Yelping Since

December 2009

Things I Love

eating, cooking, oogling expensive kitchen tools, seafood, charcuterie, dumplings, noodles, beer, grapefruit, traveling, hiking, reading, sci-fi & fantasy, anime & manga, One Piece, Radiohead, Portishead, trip-hop, Japanese culture, New York Times

My Hometown

Brooklyn, NY

When I'm Not Yelping...

I'm trying to learn to use a Mac

Why You Should Read My Reviews

I am obsessively, compulsively comprehensive with attempts at objectivity

My Second Favourite Website

http://myfigurecollect...

My First Concert

Massive Attack

Don't Tell Anyone Else But...

I adore SPAM

Most Recent Discovery

Beer pairing

Current Crush

fish tacos!