$20 for $40 Deal at Goodfellas LES

Yelp Deals
Done Deal 68 purchased
  • Reg. Price $40
  • Discount 50%
  • Savings $20

This deal ended on 3/19/2012

What You Get

  • A voucher redeemable for $40 at Goodfellas LES.
  • Two options for redeeming your voucher: Print out your voucher, or redeem on your phone with the Yelp Mobile application.

Additional Restrictions

Promotion lasts for 1 year from date of purchase. After that period, your Certificate is redeemable for the amount you paid, less any value you may have received. Not valid with other certificates or offers. Only 1 certificate(s) can be purchased for own use. Up to 3 can be purchased as gifts for others. Subject to the Yelp Deals General Terms.

Reviews for Goodfellas LES

  • 5 friends
  • 13 reviews
4.0 star rating
5/9/2012

This place has good hearty Italian meals, a cozy and clean atmosphere and great lunch specials.

Whether its the pizza or one of the various pasta meals, Goodfellas is sure to fill you up with a hearty meal and it is delicious. The service was great and the owner was very friendly and is usually working in the front of the restaurant serving tables himself.

It is definitely more of a group place. I don't see myself coming here on my own even if for lunch. The lunch specials are reasonably priced and the portions are perfect.

Overall a great place for lunch or dinner but definitely go with a few friends!

  • 6 friends
  • 26 reviews
2.0 star rating
4/30/2012

This would have been 3 stars if they had not overcharged me, the specialty pizza's are $17.95 on the website and no where does it say $23.95, the same goes for the pastas, it shows as $10 on the website and I was charged $15.  Either they didnt update their website or they left it up there to mislead customers, either way I didnt like it.

The pizza was very good but portion wise for a $23.95 pizza I expected more.
The pasta was not good at all.

  • 2 friends
  • 8 reviews
4.0 star rating
4/17/2012 1 photo

Easy enough hang out with good pizza. Great service and friendly staff. They also serve boylan bottled soda which is a nice bonus.

Try the dessert apple pie pizza if you have a sweet tooth!

3.0 star rating
4/9/2012

3.5 stars.

I was here recently and ordered their Sally Pie while my gf had the Smoking Goodfella. They were both very tasty and original, including the crunchy crust.

The service was very welcoming and professional...the fellow was one of the few waiters in the city who didn't get annoyed at my scoutmob coupon.

Their brick over is a cool sight as you walk in, but makes the bathroom in the basement a real oven as well. Btw... the bathroom was kinda dirty... that's why I didn't feel like giving them 4 stars...

  • 4 friends
  • 3 reviews
2.0 star rating
4/10/2012

I was very excited when this location opened, because the Vodka pie at the Staten Island location is my #1 favorite pizza in NYC.  We went on a weeknight.  The place was empty, and the service was fine.  The food however, was meh.  They were out of calamari, so we couldn't have that.  The bruschetta was just ok, not very crispy or flavorful.  The pizza came out small with a very soggy crust.  I was disappointed, despite going in knowing it couldn't possibly be as good as the original.

So, they have been faxing my office with lunch specials every morning.  Today we ordered the salmon and sauteed spinach lunch special.  It took 45 minutes to arrive.  The food was ok - one good thing is that they actually have croutons in the salad! Most LES places are too good for that.  I love croutons.  

I would go back if I was in the neighborhood and wanted wood-fired pizza, and I will probably order lunch now and then just for convenience of having Italian delivered.  But, it is nowhere near as good as the SI location, definitely not my favorite place in the LES, especially at the prices they charge.

About This Business

Goodfellas LES
3.5 star rating
37 reviews
144 Orchard St
New York, NY 10002
(212) 432-3200

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What am I getting?

    Simply put: one heckuva Deal. We harness the magnificent purchasing might of the Yelp community to swing you massive markdowns at highly rated local businesses. Buying here and paying upfront allows us to negotiate the best price possible — which in turn saves you money.

  • How do I redeem my Deal?

    Once you've purchased a Deal, you'll be emailed a voucher. Print it out and present it to the business, or be eco-savvy and bring it up on your handy mobile device. Different Deals have specific requirements (RSVPs, appointments necessary, etc.), so be sure to read the special terms.

  • How long can I use my Deal?

    Unless a Deal's specific terms say something different, you'll have a year to redeem the Deal for the offer indicated (e.g. a $50 value for $25); but you can subsequently redeem it for the amount you paid (e.g. the $25). For more information, read the Yelp Deals General Terms.

  • How do I keep tabs on my Deal?

    How fun is buying something if it doesn't exist? Answer: naught. As such, we've created a page for your Deals. Keep track of Deals you purchased, access your redemption vouchers, and even see how much you've saved.

  • What's the Deal with tipping?

    Gratuity is typically not included in Deals. Businesses are working hard to bring you these discounted goods and services, so please tip them with the un-discounted value of your bill in mind.

  • What if I have a problem with the Deal?

    Our goal is to make sure that every Yelper is satisfied with their Deal(s). Having problems? Email .

More Deals Nearby

See more Deals nearby