Five Guys Burgers and Fries

3.0 star rating
19 reviews Rating Details

Categories: Fast Food, Burgers  [Edit]

810 Warden Ave
Bldg C

Scarborough, ON M1L 2L6
Neighbourhood: Scarborough
(416) 755-5757
Price Range:
$$
Accepts Credit Cards:
Yes
Parking:
Private Lot
Attire:
Casual
Good for Groups:
Yes
Good for Kids:
Yes
Takes Reservations:
No
Delivery:
No
Take Away:
Yes
Waiter Service:
No
Outdoor Seating:
No
Wi-Fi:
No
Good For:
Lunch
Alcohol:
No
Drive-Thru:
No
Noise Level:
Average
Ambience:
Casual
Has TV:
No
Sort by: Yelp Sort | Date | Rating | Elites' | Facebook Friends'

19 reviews in English

  • Review from Christine R.

    Scarborough, ON

    4.0 star rating
    3/5/2012 4 photos

    You know there must be something must be good here if it's a chilly Sunday afternoon and a there's a line up to the door!
    Some might argue the prices here a little steep but they definitely make that up in quality and portion sizes.
    Burgers are made with 100% fresh never frozen ground beef, they use peanut oil, and everything on the menu is trans fat free!

    The line moved rather quickly, ironically they had 5 guys working behind the counter to keep things running smoothly.
    After you place your order you can have a seat and wait until the number on your receipt is called. To pass the time make sure you grab a handful of the free peanuts! Perfectly salted and roasted, they make for some nice nibbles to pass the time.

    The standard burger here comes with TWO patties! If your a child or weakling you can opt for the small burger which contains only one patty and best of all you can go crazy with the toppings because they all FREE!

    This is what I opted for on my Hamburger

    Toppings - Grilled onions, Grilled mushrooms, Jalapeno peppers, Tomatoes, Ketchup, Mustard, and Hot Sauce. Everything was fresh tasting even the jalapenos still had seeds to give it extra kick, nothing was sloppy and held together well.

    Meat - Both patties grilled perfectly, juicy, not overwhelmingly big, still able to take a decent size bite without dislocating my jaw.

    Bun - Soft average sesame seed bun lightly toasted with good bun to patty ratio!

    Cajun Fries - These are a must! Fresh cut perfectly fried and dusted in that addictive cajun spice! I got the large size and they were definitely huge in portion size, not only do they fill the cup crammed with fries but they run it over in the bag! I just ended up ripping open the bag and dumping the fries onto it, made for much easier eating. This could definitely feed a family of four or in my case two ladies with an appetite!

    Free peanuts, free toppings, huge portions, self serve fountain drinks (hello free refills), two patty standard juicy burgers, fast and friendly service, it totally makes sense why this place is always packed! and don't forget those Cajun Fries!!! Yum!

  • Review from E K.

    • 1 friend
    • 20 reviews

    Toronto, ON

    2.0 star rating
    4/6/2012

    The ONLY good thing about this place are their fries.  You get a huge portion of them.  We got the cajun fries and they were delicious.  I wish I could say the same for their burger.  I got the single patty, I can't eat those massive burgers and fries.

    The bun was boring, the lettuce, typical.  Free toppings aren't impressive either.

    I don't live close, but I was told to try this place.   I am used to Gourmet Burger or Hero Burger as they are far superior to this place as far as fast food burger places are concerned.

  • Review from Molly C.

    • 5 friends
    • 20 reviews

    Toronto, ON

    4.0 star rating
    2/23/2012

    Five Guys is the perfect destination in the east end for an American style, never frozen, cheese burger. The toppings are fresh and plentiful.

    I usually go for the standard ketchup, lettuce, tomato, onion, mustard, and relish. I also go for a little hamburger, but the cheese is nice melty processed, perfect for this kind of burger.

    The fries are delicious and plentiful. Cajun seasoning is nice, but unnecessary.

    Not a place for people with a nut allergy.

  • Review from Chris K.

    • 0 friends
    • 21 reviews

    Toronto, ON

    3.0 star rating
    1/15/2012

    It's a fast-food burger chain that isn't like most fast-food burger chains.

    This place blows chain burger joints out of the water. The only thing I get hung up on is the price - $15 for a regular burger (double), fries and a fountain drink. Local restaurants that offer better burgers charge less. With that price, I only go once in a blue moon.

    The first time I went they filled the bag with fries, but the last time I went they didn't, so I don't know what that is all about. It's probably for the better because the fries went to waste on my first visit because there were way too many.

    As for the burgers, they're good. I haven't had a bad experience. The meat and the toppings taste fresh. No complaints there.

  • Review from Jay M.

    • 0 friends
    • 83 reviews

    Toronto, ON

    3.0 star rating
    2/3/2012

    My feelings are pretty much just a reiteration of what has already been said, so I'll try to keep it relatively brief.

    The standard burger is 2 patties, and with cheese and bacon you're looking at just under $9 before tax. This was a pretty good burger, and my only complaint lays in that the bacon was overcooked and crunchy and lacking in flavour. The female diners I was with settled for the Little Burger or whatever they call the 1 patty equivalent, and thought it was perfectly satisfying still.
    Fries come in 2 sizes in either regular seasoning or cajun. Even the regular size ($3.49 pre tax) is more than you should need as they not only fill up the cup but also then pour a handful or fries into the bag so unless you plan on feeding a small family of 4, don't bother with the large. In fact if you even go with someone else, splitting a regular between the two of you will probably be adequate.
    Drinks are 2 sizes as well ($2.19 - $2.39 before tax), but are limited to fountain pop. Otherwise its bottled water, as they dont have any bottled juice or anything else, so hopefully you like Fruitopia if you don't drink pop.
    Bonus cool factor gained with free peanuts! You're going to be waiting a few minutes for your food to cook, so why not indulge in some free peanuts while you wait.

    All in all, a satisfying lunch and I'm glad I got to try it to find out what all the Five Guys hype is about... But there are actual restaurants where for $12 you can have a better burger and wash it down with a cold beer in a non fast food environment, so I doubt I'll be returning any time soon.

  • Review from Matt H.

    • 3 friends
    • 57 reviews

    Toronto, ON

    3.0 star rating
    11/7/2011 1 Check-in Here

    You know, I take my burgers seriously. This is the most standard american diner burger you can get. It even tastes american, but something falls short. The fries are plenty and the fountain pop is.... well... fountainy.

    I really can't say it's worth the 15 dollars to come here. It's a nice treat to take a break from the crappy food around my work and enjoy something that's a little tasty. However I was extremely close to heading next door for California Sandwiches.

    There are better burgers in Toronto.

  • Review from Mel C.

    Scarborough, ON

    3.0 star rating
    9/15/2011 2 photos

    I was excited about Five Guys Burgers since it was available only in the States for the longest time. I decided to come here for a snack after work one day.

    Aside from the great selections of free toppings for the burger, I have to say Five Guys was mediocre. I got a cheeseburger with mayo, lettuce, pickles, tomatoes, grilled onions and grilled mushrooms. It was delicious and worth a try but it's not a place I'll keep coming back to.

    I do love the concept of free peanuts that you can help yourself to as they are preparing your burger so people with peanut allergy beware!

    It's definitely more expensive than McDonald's and not as creative as Big Smoke Burger (formerly known as Craft Burger) so if you're a burger addict, go ahead try it but if you just want to try just for the sake of trying it ... save your money.

  • Review from Pauline G.

    • 3 friends
    • 12 reviews

    Toronto, ON

    3.0 star rating
    2/21/2012 2 photos

    Wasn't busy, burger was made to order and fresh but it tasted like it wasn't hot enough... Possibly due to extra fresh, extra cold lettuce and tomato? Definitely better than Johnny's around the corner and well worth the extra $.

  • Review from Tony F.

    North York, ON

    3.0 star rating
    6/20/2011

    After a month long trip to Asia, work buddies decide to take me out to Five Guys for a burger.  You'd figure after not having a hunka-slab-o-beef for a while that this would be the best thing since.. sliced hamburger patties.

    Well.. it was ok.  However, over the years, I've learned that 100% pure beef of one cut will only be so good.  The best burgers in the world are blended burgers.  Some kind of cheap cut along with some fatty ones
    like short ribs, and/or some additional gamey like meat (i.e. lamb).  

    5 guys fries were above average and loved the Cajun spice on my fries.  But the burger itself no better/worse than a Johnny's burger or a Burger hut, albeit a bit more pricey.  That alone will keep me going back to the mom and pop shops.

    Hmm I think I'll start my own chain.  2 Chicks with meat and a cup?  

    nah..

    Listed in: Meh!

    Was this review …?

  • Review from Jennifer K.

    Markham, ON

    3.0 star rating
    5/25/2011 9 photos

    Five Guys Burgers and Fries finally opened up a new location in Scarborough. Now the people in the East end or people that travels only on TTC, can give their burgers a try.

    If you ask me if Five Guys Burgers are all hype? In a way yes.. especially if you are not crazy about pan fried patties.

    I love the open kitchen, you can see all these guys working like a factory assemble lines.. (there were more than 5 guys preparing all the burgers fresh when ordered!)

    Hamburger ($6.49) with grilled onions/mushrooms, jalapeno peppers, Mayo and lettuce
    - Love how you can pick all the toppings and create your own burger..mine is the spicy version usually unless I am sharing it with a friend. jalapeno peppers was really weak tasting...
    - Patties was a little dry since cooked well done and a little bland without any seasonings... some can argue that by doing so, can taste beef in it most primitive form...

    Five Guys' burger is not going to be the burger that I daydreamed about... I love my burger's patties charcoal grilled with seasonings and this thick patties that just cooked medium... pink inside...(not going to find that in Toronto ..so I daydream about it!)

    BTW, your burger might take a little while to get ready.. I guess you can always eat some whole shelled peanuts while you wait!! I hope you are not allergic to nuts!

    One big difference between 5 guys chain in US and Toronto, no calories information are posted with the menu... If you see how much calories those little burgers has.. I don't think you would have get your side order of fries with it!!

  • Review from Jon-Jon G.

    • 4 friends
    • 17 reviews

    Scarborough, ON

    3.0 star rating
    7/28/2011

    My first experience with Five Guys was last summer in Long Island which was a phenomenal experience (and no, this is not a reference to Fire Island!), so you can only imagine how I excited I was when they opened up shop in Scarborough.

    Despite being one of the unhealthiest burger joints, I had to get my fix. In both instances, I've opted for the little burger, which has one patty (with two patties being the norm at this joint). When I first had it, I didn't realize the unlimited options when it came to toppings so stuck with the standard toppings and condiments of lettuce, tomato, ketchup. With so many options to choose from (and at no extra cost), I went a bit overboard with the toppings this time around. I mean, who's gonna say no to grilled onions and mushrooms?! I learned my lesson that 'less is more' and the combination of all the toppings really took away from my overall satisfaction of the burger.

    As for the fries, I'd have to pass on future visits. If you can look past the unhealthiness of peanut oil, and prefer largely sliced, mushy fries, then by all means, go for it. The Cajun seasoning didn't really do anything for me either.

    It's definitely going to be awhile until my next visit, perhaps on a day when I feel like splurging. And my next burger will be plain and simple, with no excessive nonsense!

  • Review from WaYnE c.

    • 86 friends
    • 871 reviews

    Maple, ON

    3.0 star rating
    6/9/2011

    Hamburger(2 PAT/$6.49)

    I had an Angus Third Pounder @McD earlier and the Patty taste, smell, and felt quite similar.  Obviously there are slight differences overall but with this note, I'm not sure if Five Guys is overly status-quo or McD making competitive improvements.

    Why does the Burger Bun always get dented?  
    Is that a characteristic of a good Burger?
    Can't complain about FREE Nuts, just can't.

    Painted Metallic chairs to look like Wooden chairs.

  • Review from Greg P.

    • 0 friends
    • 15 reviews

    Toronto, ON

    3.0 star rating
    6/6/2011

    The search for the best burger - 2011 Review #2.
    A lot of fanfare goes with this joint. Mostly from the US. I got the banquet burger. One patty with bacon. It was thin and overdone. The buns are toasted. YEAH. The Cajun fries are horrible and the regular fries are ok. Will somebody please educate burger joints on double frying. The only consolation is free refills, unless you order take out. I won't be going back. Look for review #3. Still searching.

  • Review from A.J. S.

    Toronto, ON

    3.0 star rating
    1/23/2012 1 Check-in Here

    The hamburgers here are really good, and the french fries here are really good.  The combination of fresh cut fries and the burger is pretty good. The selection of toppings is fun to play with. However, it's really overpriced, and I don't think they provide a product which is worth the amount that you spend here.

  • Review from Heather B.

    Scarborough, ON

    3.0 star rating
    5/29/2011

    An American Chain has landed in Toronto.

    I have to admit they make a mean burger but I think they are over rated as well.
    I had the mini cheeseburger which is one patty.  A reg one has 2 patties.
    One order of fries is good for 2 people.

    I enjoy the fact that they make the burger when you order on their grill so everything is freshly made, hot and not lying around.
    The toppings are great as well... I LOVE mushrooms, and hot peppers option.
    They are a little pricey for a burger joint - 2 burgers, 2 drinks and one order of fries came to about $22.

    And like Jennifer said - I hope no one is allergic to peanuts because you can munch on those while you wait.

    Overall I dunno if they will last - They don't really overtop Harvey's or Licks in my opinion.

  • Review from Mike P.

    • 0 friends
    • 10 reviews

    Scarborough, ON

    4.0 star rating
    3/22/2012

    I've eaten here twice and loved it both times, definitely a quick and dirty meal before catching a flick at the movies nearby.  The meat is fantastic, as others have said, it's sort of a fast food chain burger with a mom and pop taste.  The fries are pretty good, the first time I went I felt they were a tad undercooked.  The second time they were darker and had a much better flavour.  They do literally take two scoops and throw them in the bag, I love that! Best way to eat it is to tear the bag open and munch away.  i could never eat a large fries here and I'm a fry fanatic.  I can't wait till they buckle and offer poutine.  Johnny's burgers is terrible, this place owns it.  I would still say T-Bones has a better homeburger but this hits the spot!

  • Review from Joanne S.

    • 4 friends
    • 44 reviews

    Toronto, ON

    4.0 star rating
    5/31/2011

    Five Guys isn't a place you stop by everyday for lunch, mainly because you'd die before your tenth visit and you'll be broke.

    The burgers are delicious if you like thin, crusted patties that are made to order on a pan top. They are not grilled and they are not thick. As far as I know they're unseasoned. Do yourself a favour and get the regular cheeseburger, not the mini wuss (unless you eat here everyday...).

    The regular fries are good for two, but they're not as generous as the Five Guy's in America. The cajun fries are gross, but I know a few who love them...to each their own.

    Drink are self-serve and free refills, so really you only have to get one cup and two straws if you're willing to compromise with your fine dining partner.

    If you're allergic to peanuts, run away! The fries are fried in peanut oil and there are boxes of shelled peanuts there for customers to help themselves to.

    I like my burger with grilled onion, mushrooms, pickles and lite ketchup (yes they do "lite" and can even go lite on lettuce). Not sure about this location but in general the jalapenos are fresh and not the pickled kind you get at a hot dog stand.

  • Review from Howard H.

    Toronto, ON

    2.0 star rating
    8/19/2011 1 Check-in Here

    I am very familiar with this chain going all way back to their humble origins in the Washington D.C. area in the early 90s.  They were consistently voted the # 1 burger in the local mags down there. Although I am not immune to the allure of grilled beef on bread, I never saw what made them so great.  Although my initial pronouncement (back in the day) of 5 Guys being a post-modern Fuddruckers seems a bit dated, the sentiment still holds.  This isn't a truly better burger; it's a fresher burger - it has more options - it's bigger - all good-ish things that somehow in my mouths mind don't add up to better.  There are loads of better mom-n-pop burgers in the GTA and if you need a chain burger to feel secure, well IMHO Hero is a much better choice.

  • Review from wendy l.

    • 0 friends
    • 10 reviews

    Scarborough, ON

    3.0 star rating
    6/20/2011

    Good real hamburger, but I'm really disappointed in the the front of the house.  It's just like everything else in Scarborough.  After a few weeks of being open, the "new canadians" throw trash on the floor, and leave stuff all over the tables.  On Fathers day, there was 1 clean table to choose from.
    I've visited 3 stores in the states and all three had a staff member working on tables lining up chairs sweeping the floor etc.  If the eating part looks like crap what will the washrooms look like.  I was thrilled they were coming to Toronto, but wish they would keep it clean!

People Who Viewed This Also Viewed...

People Viewed This After Searching For...